From the Alter Steps

Crimson Peak, directed by Guillermo del Toro, is not a traditional horror film, it’s a gothic romance dressed in ghostly silk and dripping red clay. More Brontë than jump scare, the film is a lavish love letter to classic gothic literature, where the real monsters are human obsession, grief, and control.

Set in the late 19th century, the story follows Edith Cushing, an aspiring writer who believes ghosts are metaphors rather than threats. After a whirlwind romance, she marries the enigmatic Sir Thomas Sharpe and relocates to his decaying ancestral home, Allerdale Hall, dubbed Crimson Peak for the blood-red clay that bleeds through the snow. There, Edith encounters not only restless spirits, but Thomas’s unsettling sister, Lucille, whose devotion to her brother borders on something far darker.

What makes Crimson Peak compelling is its clarity of intent. Del Toro never pretends this is a mystery to be solved. The film tells you early on that the house is haunted and that danger is inevitable. The tension comes not from what will happen, but from why, and whether love, knowledge, or survival will win out.

Visually, the film is breathtaking. Every frame feels hand-painted: flowing gowns, candlelit corridors, creaking staircases, and walls that literally seep with color and memory. The ghosts themselves are tragic rather than terrifying, warnings etched in bone and shadow. Practical effects and elaborate set design make Allerdale Hall feel alive, as though the house itself is complicit in the story unfolding within it.

Mia Wasikowska brings quiet resolve to Edith, but the film truly belongs to Jessica Chastain as Lucille Sharpe. Her performance is operatic, restrained, and ferocious, a woman consumed by love, entitlement, and rage. She is not merely a villain, but the embodiment of gothic obsession taken to its inevitable, horrifying end.

Crimson Peak is a sumptuous, melancholic gothic romance that prioritizes atmosphere, emotion, and tragedy over fear. It won’t satisfy viewers looking for relentless scares, but for those who love haunted houses, doomed love, and beautiful decay, it’s an unforgettable descent into darkness.

If you’d like to support my writing and help keep this blog running (books, films, hosting, and far too much coffee), you can leave a tip or buy me a coffee. Every bit of support helps me keep creating thoughtful reviews and deep dives into dark, beautiful stories. Thank you for reading.